21 October, 2012

Historian on the Edge: Professor Grumpy's Historical Manifesto

Historian on the Edge: Professor Grumpy's Historical Manifesto: Knowing 'what really happened in history' is Chronicling not history. And it isn't much practical use outside pub quizzes*. 1: It reduces history to simple fact-finding; and simple factual recounting isn’t history. 2: It assumes that the simple course of events explains them, and thus that the course of events naturally, inevitably, led to particular outcomes (where we are today). 3: Our modern nationalists aren’t operating under compulsion from the Past. The past has no power; it’s dead and gone. It can’t make you do anything. These people are choosing events from their understanding of the past to justify what they are doing or what they want to do in the present.